Monday, August 11, 2008

Cut-n-Paste-gate

The WayneWho staff received an e-mail with what amounts to a very serious charge of possible plagiarism or at least some level of copyright infringement based on Mr. Hennecy's campaign website. It seems that the website for Mr. Byron Hennecy is pretty much a direct knock-off of the one for United States Senator, Gordon Smith (Rep) of Oregon. If you take a look at both websites http://byronhennecy.com/ and http://gordonsmith.com/ you will instantly see they are very similar to each other. These areas of similarity caused the WayneWho staff to dig a little bit deeper into who U.S. Senator Gordon Smith is, and why he would steal Mr. Hennecy's campaign website. A serious charge we know, but the truth must be uncovered.

The charge of plagiarism is no small one, and the WayneWho staff realized that if we were going to take on a sitting US Senator for stealing not only the look of Mr. Hennecy's campaign, but much of his wording as well, then we needed to investigate this Senator. Mr. Smith is a well respected Republican leader who was recently criticized for trying to tie himself to Senator Obama and his presidential bid to soften his Republican image. We figured this is where the idea must have come from to steal a once Republican turned Democrat local candidate's campaign message, so we sought out some smart people to help us find the evidence and solve this technology riddled case.




By bribing our grandchildren with a good amount of ice-cream we soon discovered amazing similarities in the web sites. As we looked at each page of information side by side, we could easily see the similarities:

From Byron Hennecy's 'About' Page:
Byron Hennecy has served his home state of Florida in the County since 1999 and the Fire Department since 2003. He has earned a reputation for independence and effectiveness, working with both Republicans and Democrats to do what is right for our County.

From Gordon Smith's 'About' Page:
Gordon Smith has served his home state of Oregon in the United States Senate since 1997. He has earned a reputation for independence and effectiveness, working with both Republicans and Democrats to do what is right for Oregon.

From Byron Hennecy's 'Roots' Page:
Thank you for your interest in Byron's GrassRoots. Over the next year, Byron's GrassRoots will be a highly visible and active part of Byron’s campaign that will involve people from across the county working together to elect Byron and benefit Democratic candidates throughout Florida. Our goal is to build Byron's GrassRoots into one of the largest grassroots campaign organizations in our county’s history and with your help we’ll reach that goal.

From Gordon Smith's 'SmithRoots' Page:
Thank you for your interest in SmithRoots. Over the next year, SmithRoots will be a highly visible and active part of Senator Smith’s campaign that will involve people from across the state working together to re-elect Senator Smith and benefit Republican candidates throughout Oregon. Our goal is to build SmithRoots into one of the largest grassroots campaign organizations in our state’s history and with your help we’ll reach that goal.

Even the first page promise of 'Cutting Taxes' read the exact same on both web sites: "Byron Hennecy believes you should keep as much of your hard-earned money as possible..."

We wanted more proof of the crime, so with a little urging and the promise of Happy Meals, the real truth was discovered. Technology people and grandchildren know how to read the code that makes up any website. Kids today are much like the characters in the movie the Matrix that can look at a screen filled with weird symbols and make sense of it. It is deep in this code where we found the truth. If you go to the page http://byronhennecy.com/about.aspx and then click on the 'View' menu button at the top of your internet explorer and then click on the 'Source' button on the list that appears (we recommend asking a younger person to help you). A new screen will appear that shows a bunch of strange signs. Ignore all of this. On the scroll bar on the right of this window, scroll down about half way. You will see a line that reads "Helping grow the Oregon economy is a top priority. As a member of the powerful Senate Finance Committee, Gordon is using his clout to cut taxes and help working families keep more of their hard-earned money." You will also see a line that says "Gordon Smith is making public policy that does not leave Oregonians high and dry." Yep, we felt pretty stupid too. We did not expect to find Gordon Smith's campaign message hidden on Byron Hennecy's website. We would like to apologized to the Gordon Smith Campaign for thinking they were the ones who had copied a website.

At this point we had to wonder if all the "Green Building" messages Mr. Hennecy had been writing about were his own ideas or if they were somebody else'. Maybe this wasn't Mr. Hennecy's fault, but that of his campaign staff, or his campaign consultant Shawn Van Dusen of Fortis Management Group who had also worked on the campaign of St Cloud City Council Member Tom Griffin. Mr. Van Dusen has been writing lengthy essays for St. Cloud in The News to educate all of us on his theories of economic development. Or maybe the consultant running the campaign is really the campaign itself with Mr. Hennecy being the willing puppet who will do anything or say anything to get elected? The scary part about politicians is that in the absence of the consultants used during a campaign, special interests become the voice of truth after the election is over.

We understand that the problems we face in this community are dire, but the fake-it-till-you-make-it mentality has been an ongoing problem with Osceola County politicians. Candidates should also learn to trust the voters of this community. Voters of this community, when told the truth, are capable of making the right decisions. Lying to the voters is what messes up the whole process.

For now we will leave you with a quick note that we have e-mailed the Gordon Smith Campaign and our local media sources with all of the original material we were sent. We cannot take credit for these findings and offer our thanks to those who keep us informed and on track. I guess we will just have to wait for any type of response from the affected campaigns.

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

I would guess that Byron did not make this website on his own.

Anonymous said...

To the commenter above, I think that is the point Wayne is trying to make. These guys don't do anything on their own...

Anonymous said...

The campaign has already changed the code to hide it. Typical. If Byron cannot run his own small campaign, how in the world does he think he can run this county?

Anonymous said...

I would be firing that consultant or whoever collected money for that website. It hasn't even worked right since day one.

Anonymous said...

C'mon Byron, what kind of campaign steals a US Senator's website? You can't steal solutions to fix our county's problems. Fake it 'til we make it. Your right on WayneWho.

Anonymous said...

If this is his consultants fault, I'd be asking for my money back and looking for a new consultant!
If not... it will look like Bryon approves of this!

Anonymous said...

Isn't this Griffin's guy? Chris at St Cloud in the News has been talkin Hennecy up. She was a big Griffin pusher. That's done
St Cloud a lot of good. NOT! Here's another cheat brought to you by Chris Falkowski and Tom Griffin. Also by there little puppet-Shawn Van Dusen.

Anonymous said...

They've already changed the code on the Mutimedia page. Admission of guilt? This is unbelievable.
He's running for County Commissioner. Who in the world would be so stupid as to have a campaign steal a Senator's website?

Anonymous said...

Bet those firemen are real happy about that endorsement now. We endorse the cheat who is one of their own.

Anonymous said...

This just shows that you can't trust any of these guys.

Anonymous said...

Wow; you guys are on a hair trigger :) There is no mystery here- it's called a Template. May web sites developed by the same person will look alike. No need to reinvent the wheel if you have already developed a similar site. This is a common practice for software and web developers; they all have a library of previous work so as to get the job done for a similar project faster and cheaper for the next guy.

Anonymous said...

Yes, it is trivial to steal the content of a web site, but the template explanation is just as plausible. Now if you found out that different people developed the two sites... oops! I just hate it when they get busted, don't you??

Anonymous said...

Template? What kind of template has a Senator from the other side of the country's political verbage and stances as well as text codes on the page. You buy blank templates not a cut-and-paste website. Do you know anything about the web? Here goes the Hennecy shuffle, get ready for it!

Anonymous said...

So you are saying that Byron is using template campaign issues from a republican in Oregon? Oregonians and Floridians have different issues that don't come from templates.

Anonymous said...

Two possibilities: Same guy did both sites or it was a copy-and-paste theft of the source. Simple as that. I wouldn't go off the deep end until you can say with certainty that the same person didn't build both sites. I often tell folks interested in getting a web site to find one you like and get that same person to do yours. That way you get the look and feel of your site the way you want it. Yell and scream all you want, this is a possible explanation... If different people did in fact do both sites then by all means have at 'em until they squeal for mercy :)

Anonymous said...

Looks and sounds like Hennecy still has his consultant on staff!
There's always an explanation in politics but never and answer.

Anonymous said...

I looked at both sights and they both have the same exact wording, just different names. What exactly does Byron Hennecy stand for without Gordon Smith's campaign? At least in his own words?

Anonymous said...

A template allows you to put your platforms and campaigns in your own words. I've worked with website templates and this seems more plagarized. There is a lot of explaining to do here!

Anonymous said...

Nope, just an IT guy who got an email earlier today about this blog. Too busy to get that deep into politics...

Anonymous said...

Interesting - I went to the Hennecy site this morning after y'all broke the story and then again just now to show my co-worker. Sure enough, they are already changing it. Seems to me if they could do it that fast, maybe they should have done it right in the first place.

Anonymous said...

I agree. It looks like Hennecy is like the rest of those idiots up there. Don't do anything right until you're caught.

Anonymous said...

Well now we know why Byron keeps having to hold fundraising fishing derbys. He has to keep paying his staff to copy ideas for him.

Anonymous said...

The picture you are showing of his web site does not look like the website he has up now. Did he change his site to look different?

Anonymous said...

So now we have to listen to Hennecy's people say this is some type of template conspiracy when the evidence points to theft. Just be honest and say we screwed up!

Anonymous said...

I liked his "Gordon Smith" site better than what they have changed it to. Maybe they can just ask the Senator if they can keep using his site?

Anonymous said...

You better believe it. Probably got a call from
Sen. Gordon Smith.
I'd be embarrassed to be caught with my pants down like Hennecy has.

Anonymous said...

Did anyone else notice that his consultant is being quoted on the website, talking about his abilities and what we really need. Does that really count as a recommendation, when your PAID consultant is recommending you?!

Anonymous said...

I guess I will just have to vote for Chuck Dunnick.

Anonymous said...

Chuck Dunnick? I guess so. Better the devil you know.

Anonymous said...

I don't think so. Neither of these guys matter.
Harrell has the Democrats and Hawkins has the Republicans going into November.

Anonymous said...

Who would ever vote for Dunnick?
Lane would crush him again even without the wife beating scandal. Byron just doesn't have what it takes. I know the guy and he's nice enough, but he just doesn't have a clue about politics.

Anonymous said...

Wife Beating Scandal?

Who was the wife beating?

Anonymous said...

Actually...he didn't steal the site...both candidates are cheap and simply used a website template service instead of having a custom one designed.

Anonymous said...

If your template theory is correct, then are you saying that the name Gordon Smith and his position just happened to already be on the template that was purchased?? WOW! How cool is that?! Wouldn't it be great for all candidates if their name just happened to already be on a template? Maybe if that was the case, then Byron should have looked harder for one that existed with him name!

Anonymous said...

So is that the official response from the Hennecy camp is that they screwed up when putting up their web site template?